Literature Review

15 Best AI Research Assistant Tools For Enhanced Productivity

Discover the 14 best AI research assistant tools to streamline workflow and boost productivity. Find the perfect solution for efficient research.

Aug 24, 2024

Lady Working -  Research Assistant
Lady Working -  Research Assistant
Lady Working -  Research Assistant

The process of writing a research paper can be daunting. The prospect of conducting a comprehensive literature search to produce a high-quality research paper for your class can be overwhelming. Where do I start? What if I miss something important? How do I organize all of this information?

If you have ever asked yourself these questions, you are not alone. The good news is that you can tackle these challenges with help. This guide will provide valuable insights on how you can enlist the help of an AI research assistant to improve your next literature search and help you write a better research paper.

Otio’s AI research and writing partner can help you achieve your academic goals, like writing efficient research papers and getting fabulous study material with AI. This tool will speed up your literature search, find relevant study material, and help you organize your findings to produce a top-notch research paper.

Table Of Contents

What is A Research Assistant?

Person Working on Laptop - Research Assistant

Research institutes employ research assistants to assist with academic or private research. A research assistant's primary responsibility is to support either a research fellow or a research team through collecting, analyzing, and interpreting data. Institutes that use research assistants include universities, research centers (e.g., the Russell Group), and private organizations. Research assistants usually operate temporarily, though permanent positions exist. 

In an academic setting, research assistants work under the supervision of research fellows. Research assistant roles are often undertaken by postgraduate students completing their PhD program. This provides income for the doctoral student and prepares them for an academic career once their program is complete. However, you can also use AI tools such as Otio as research assistants for enhanced and quick academic research.

Is There an AI Research Assistant?

Laptop Laying - Research Assistant

The Surprising Ways AI Can Alleviate the Burden of Research and Help You Write Faster

If you’ve ever done academic research, you know it can feel overwhelming. There’s an awful lot of information out there, and it’s only getting worse as more folks have access to the internet and can publish their thoughts with the click of a button. While you can use traditional methods to get through research and writing your paper,  like bookmarking articles, jotting down notes, and creating an outline, these approaches can be tedious, disjointed, and slow. 

Fortunately, recent advances in artificial intelligence can help you radically improve how you tackle academic research. AI tools, like Otio, can help you organize your research and even assist you in writing your paper. Here’s how:

1. Collect and Organize Your Research with Otio

The first step in academic research is to collect and organize your sources. Otio can help you do this with far less stress than traditional methods. Instead of bookmarking articles and PDFs, taking notes in a separate application, and manually creating an outline, you can use Otio to help you collect and organize your research in one place. 

Otio allows you to gather information from various sources, including articles, YouTube videos, tweets, and books. The tool also helps you extract meaningful information from your sources and organize it so you can reference it later easily.  

2. Extract Key Takeaways with AI-Generated Notes

Once you’ve collected a decent amount of research, you can start reading and taking notes. This part can be tedious and time-consuming, especially if you have a long list of sources to get through. Otio helps you tackle this part of research faster with AI-generated notes. 

Instead of reading each source and taking notes on what you think is essential, you can use Otio to get summaries and key points on all your sources. The AI does this quickly, so you can move on to writing your paper without a long delay.  

3. Create a Draft Using Your Organized Research

Otio helps you write research papers and essays faster. Once you’ve collected and organized your research, you can use the tool to help you create a first draft of your paper. This is a great way to overcome writer’s block and ease the transition into academic writing. 

Let Otio be your AI research and writing partner — try Otio for free today!

Related Reading

Systematic Review Vs Meta Analysis
Impact Evaluation
How To Critique A Research Article
How To Synthesize Sources
Annotation Techniques
Skimming And Scanning
Types Of Literature Reviews
Literature Review Table
Literature Review Matrix
How To Increase Reading Speed And Comprehension
How To Read Research Papers
How To Summarize A Research Paper
Literature Gap

Benefits of Using AI Research Assistant

Lady Sitting in Work Table - Research Assistant

1. Using AI Tools to Acquire Research Knowledge and Literature Review  

AI-powered research tools for reading, annotating, and note-taking can make acquiring knowledge more efficient. Such tools can provide the user excerpts from the literature source, highlighting the most relevant information and helping one decide whether an article is worth reading. 

This can help the user quickly locate pertinent information in research articles, determine which paragraphs to read in-depth, and compile notes on the subject. To use such an AI-powered tool most effectively for research, the users should critically assess the output without accepting it as ‘the truth’ and read the original text instead of simply relying on AI-generated summaries. 

Example

A researcher uses a tool like Mendeley or Zotero to organize their literature. The tool automatically generates citations and bibliographies and suggests relevant articles based on the researcher's existing library. 

2. Using AI for Academic Writing 

Distilling complex information from numerous sources and explaining it along with one’s original ideas is essential to good academic writing. Effective note-taking systems that track the source information and help avoid plagiarism are critical for this process. AI-powered tools help take and organize relevant notes to be included in one’s write-up and help the researcher write an article effectively. 

Some AI tools also allow the researcher to paraphrase sentences from the notes they have taken. Such tools are essential and helpful for researchers from non-English speaking countries. To make the most effective use of AI tools for academic writing, researchers must not solely rely on AI for note-taking or writing. Researchers can also practice more ethical writing by reformulating the paraphrased content from AI rather than copy-pasting the paraphrased content. 

Example

A researcher uses a grammar checker like Grammarly to identify and correct errors in their writing. 

3. Using AI for Research Planning and Study Design

AI-powered experimental design tools use machine learning algorithms to optimize parameters. Automating experimental design processes can help researchers reduce the time and effort required to design studies, freeing up more data analysis and interpretation time. Such AI tools can also reduce human errors and R&D costs. 

Researchers must consider various variables and parameters to use AI tools to create experimental design models effectively. By inputting specific criteria into such models, researchers can generate optimal designs that maximize their study effectiveness and effectively use AI tools to develop experimental design models. Researchers can generate optimal designs that maximize their study effectiveness by inputting particular criteria into such models.

Example

A researcher uses a tool like JMP to design experiments, optimizing factors like sample size and experimental conditions. 

4. Using AI for Data Analysis

While traditional data analysis methods relied on manual processes and limited computational capabilities, AI-powered data analysis tools have revolutionized the field. Such tools use machine learning algorithms to interpret, extract, and uncover patterns in vast datasets. This can reduce time and cost and increase the efficiency of research output. 

To effectively use AI tools for data analysis, researchers must clearly define the objectives of their project and identify the specific insights and outcomes they want to achieve through the study. They must also gather relevant data and ensure it is clean, well-structured, and suitable for analysis. Finally, it is also essential that the researchers identify and determine which AI tools and algorithms are most appropriate for their analysis goals. 

Example

A data scientist uses Python libraries like Pandas and Scikit-learn to analyze a large dataset and identify patterns and trends. 

5. Using AI for Peer Review Assistance

The volume of peer review submissions is constantly growing. Reducing screening and reviewing time can save millions of working hours and boost academic productivity. AI-powered peer review tools can create the potential for semi-automated peer review systems where low-quality or controversial studies could be flagged, and reviewers could be matched with manuscripts from their subject-matter expertise.

Although AI cannot perform peer review yet, AI tools can be effectively used in the peer review process to suggest appropriate journals for an article, perform initial quality control for submitted manuscripts, and find reviewers. 

Example

A journal uses an AI tool like Otio to screen submissions for plagiarism and identify potential conflicts of interest.

Related Reading

Literature Search Template
ChatGPT Prompts For Research
How To Find Gaps In Research
Research Journal Example
How To Find Limitations Of A Study
How To Do A Literature Search
Research Concept Map
Meta-Analysis Methods
How To Identify Bias In A Source
Search Strategies For Research
Literature Search Template
How To Read A Research Paper Quickly
How To Evaluate An Article
ChatGPT Summarize Paper
How To Take Notes For A Research Paper
AI in Research
Can You Use "We" in a Research Paper

14 Best AI Research Assistant Tools For Enhanced Productivity

Laptop And Book Laying - Research Assistant

1. Otio: The Ultimate AI Workspace for Researchers  

Otio’s innovative AI-native tool is designed to streamline the research workflow. Knowledge workers, researchers, and students today need help with content overload and are left to deal with it using fragmented, complex, and manual tooling. 

Too many settle for stitching together complicated bookmarking, read-it-later, and note-taking apps to get through their workflows. Now that anyone can create content with a button, this problem will only worsen. Otio solves this problem by providing researchers with one AI-native workspace. It helps them: 

1. Collect a wide range of data sources, from bookmarks, tweets, and extensive books to YouTube videos. 

2. Extract key takeaways with detailed AI-generated notes and source-grounded Q&A chat. 

3. Create draft outputs using the sources you’ve collected. 

Otio helps you to go from the reading list to the first draft faster. Along with this, Otio also enables you to write research papers/essays faster. Here are our top features that researchers love: 

AI-generated notes on all bookmarks (Youtube videos, PDFs, articles, etc.), Otio enables you to chat with individual links or entire knowledge bases, just like you chat with ChatGPT, as well as AI-assisted writing. Let Otio be your AI research and writing partner — try Otio for free today!  

2. Bit AI: The Smart Collaboration Tool

Bit AI is an AI program designed to help teams collaborate on documents, wikis, and knowledge bases. It goes beyond just text and images, allowing users to create interactive documents containing videos, cloud files, and audio. It works much like Google Drive, allowing for real-time collaboration on documents. Multiple people can work on documents simultaneously and chat with one another within the interface. 

Pros

  • AI Writing AssistantAI Genius is the perfect tool for generating documents, wikis, and other information based on a text prompt. 

  • Multiple Use Cases: However, due to its document development features, AI is great for researchers and marketers, product management, startups, and human resources. 

  • Collaboration ToolsBit.ai allows multiple users to collaborate on documents, notes, wikis, and other real-time content. 

  • Wide Range of IntegrationBit AI integrates with many third-party tools, including YouTube, Google Sheets, Figma, and GitHub. 

Cons 

  • Limited CustomizationsBit AI would be better if it had text formatting or options to customize the appearance of documents, such as matching company branding.  

3. Semantic Scholar: The AI Research Tool for Computer Science and Biomedical Research  

Semantic Scholar is one of the top AI tools for research, and it is widely used by students pursuing computer science, biomedical science, and neuroscience. It uses natural language processing to analyze academic papers and find relevant literature. Besides, Semantic Scholar offers detailed overviews of research topics and can identify the most critical parts of a paper, making it a valuable AI tool for research. 

Pros

  • Refine search results for greater efficiency and relevance. Continuously improves the tool based on user feedback and provides a personalized user experience. 

Cons 

  • The summary has accuracy issues and AI-generated citations. It only gives you access to the full text of some papers.  

4. Scite: The AI Tool That’s Changing How We Read Research Papers  

Scite is one of the most popular AI-powered academic research tools that improve academic research in one go. Its own natural language processing and machine learning help users do better research on scholarly articles and analyze citations. 

Moreover, Scite allows researchers like you to assess the dependability of references in any particular context. It helps in evaluating the quality and impact of the research. It also provides better visualizations and metrics to understand the citation landscape of a specific paper or topic. If you have missed out on using this tool, try it today. 

Pros 

  • Innovative Citations: Scite analyzes how an article is referenced in other research. It can tell if the citing article supports, contradicts, or mentions the original article. 

  • Citation Context: Scite shows you how different sections of an article are cited in other research, helping you understand how the original research is being used and interpreted by other researchers. 

  • Citation Reports: This tool generates reports that show citation patterns and trends, helping users identify articles and authors in a related field. 

  • Large Dataset: Scite was training on more than 187 million articles, books, preprints, and other datasets, making it a solid choice for researchers. 

Cons 

  • Not All Articles Cited Are Accessible: Although Scite offers full-text access for most articles cited, some publishers have not.  

5. Google Scholar: The Best Free Tool for Academic Research  

Google Scholar is a beacon for academic research, offering a straightforward platform akin to its browser counterpart. It’s a treasure trove of recent articles, research papers, and scholarly literature, simplifying the quest for up-to-date information with easy-to-identify tags for quick access. 

Pros

  • Use natural language searching to find academic and literature topics. Allow your search for gray literature for systematic reviews. 

Cons 

  • The content you find will not be reviewed thoroughly, and there are concerns about source credibility. You need to show significant literature topics.  

6. PDFGear Copilot: The AI Tool for Researching PDFs  

PDFgear Copilot is an AI-powered assistant that extracts and summarizes information in PDF documents. It utilizes OpenAI’s ChatGPT language model to help users locate important information in documents while conducting research. It lets you chat with a document, ask questions about its contents, and quickly summarize entire PDFs. 

Pros 

  • Interact With PDFs: Summarize, analyze, and interact with PDF content through natural language processing. ChatGPT Integration: 

  • Find critical information and get answers by using built-in ChatGPT functionality. 

  • Streamline PDF Workflows: Complete tasks, such as converting, printing, and saving PDFs with natural language processing. 

  • Support for Multiple Languages: PDFgear Copilot supports over 100 languages, making it accessible to many users. 

Cons 

  • No Dark Mode: PDFgear cannot switch to dark mode, potentially alienating those who prefer it.  

7. Consensus: The AI Research Assistant for Science  

Consensus is a research tool that gathers information from published material and peer-reviewed articles. The tool is helpful for those who want to understand scientific subjects thoroughly. It helps users understand scientific subjects thoroughly by scanning for trustworthy and accurate research articles. This tool is handy for students and researchers in STEM and business fields. 

Pros 

  • Natural language processing is used to analyze data and verify the source. 

  • It also generates a summary of research queries and helps obtain information for the early research stage. 

Cons 

  • It is favored only for STEM and business, not the humanities and fine arts. It is not suitable for rigorous and reproducible research.  

8. Trinka: The AI Tool for Academic Writing  

It is one of the most commonly used AI tools for scholars and students. It helps with grammar and language correction for academic and technical writing. It has 3000+ grammar checks and tone and style enhancements, which allow scholars to write better theses and projects without errors. 

Trinka enables you to document scientific findings and allows you to have a more technical tone and style without any difficulty. Therefore, Trinka is the most promising tool for academic research, as it helps better document research papers and white papers. 

Pros: 

  • Save time checking grammar while writing academic papers. 

  • Let you check grammar, correct spelling, and offer context suggestions based on your writing style. 

Cons 

  • The tool's response time could be faster, hindering quick feedback. 

  • It may also be challenging to understand the technical jargon.  

9. Connected Papers: The Visual Literature Review Tool  

Connected Papers is an innovative research tool that helps scientists and scholars efficiently explore relevant literature by providing a visual, similarity-based mapping of related academic papers. It uses circles to represent different papers. The size of the circle corresponds to the frequency of citations by other researchers. 

Papers that closely resemble the original paper you provided are positioned closer together and connected by lines. The thickness of the line indicates the strength of the relationship between the documents. By following the connections between papers, you can use Connected Papers to explore new research areas within your field. 

Pros 

  • Similarity Graphs: Connected Papers produces a visual graph displaying related papers. However, unlike a traditional citation tree, it emphasizes semantic similarity, meaning that documents with shared citations and references are more connected. 

  • Prior and Derivative Works: Connected Papers identifies influential prior works that have shaped the current research landscape. Additionally, it can reveal derivative works that build upon the original paper’s ideas. 

  • Multi-Origin Graphs: You can enter multiple papers as a starting point so that CP can create a combined graph highlighting their relationships. 

  • Save Papers and Graphs: Save papers and graphs to revisit and explore topics further. 

Cons 

  • Limited Citation View: Unlike citation trees, Connected Papers doesn’t directly show how papers cite each other.  

10. Mendeley: The Free AI Tool for Organizing Research  

Mendeley is a user-friendly AI tool for organizing, sharing, and citing research papers properly in one place. It helps you quickly manage PDFs, create better bibliographies, and annotate documents. Moreover, this tool enables researchers to collaborate on projects and discover relevant articles based on their interests. 

Mendeley’s powerful features and integration into academic workflows make it a practical tool. It helps streamline your management and enhance collaboration within the scholarly community. 

Pros

  • Offer journal citation styles and boost citation efficiency. 

  • Organize and share references for collaborative research. 

Cons 

  • Do not make PDF annotations as expected. 

  • Users commonly face server downtime and syncing errors.  

11. Litmaps: The Literature Mapping Tool  

Litmaps is a literature mapping tool that helps researchers discover new and relevant research papers, visualize the relationships between papers, and share their research. It works by using connectedness theory, which allows researchers to quickly scan Litmap’s network of academic papers around the documents they know, discovering vital related papers they may not know about. Litmaps can also generate reading lists and notify users when relevant new papers are published, making it easier to stay up-to-date on the latest research. 

Pros 

  • Search Academic Papers: Litmaps allows you to search a vast database of over 260 million academic papers to find relevant articles. 

  • Mind Mapping: Litmaps lets you visualize your research by creating a map of interconnected articles and annotating them for better understanding. 

  • Explore Research From Various Angles: Dynamic Exploration allows users to explore research from different angles by rearranging how papers are positioned on the map. 

  • Collaboration Features: The platform enables you to share your research maps with colleagues, students, or advisors to facilitate collaboration. 

Cons 

  • Limited Free Plan: Some features, like unlimited searches, are only available on paid plans.  

12. Scholarcy: The Research Paper Summarizer  

Scholarly is an AI tool that improves academic research by automating the process of reading, summarizing, and extracting information. It can help you recognize figures, tables, and references from articles and grasp the main concepts. Additionally, this tool has citation extraction features that allow users to organize and cite the sources used in the research. It also provides the literature review process, which enables you to save valuable time and effort. 

Pros

  • Summarize the topics of research papers to save time and effort. 

  • Offer links to the cited resources to access the research material. 

Cons 

  • The essay summary may need to be more precise, which may result in plagiarism. 

  • The AI-generated summary will only cover some of the critical points of the research paper.  

13. Jenni: The AI Writing Assistant for Students  

The following AI tool for research on our list is Jenni. It’s an AI-powered writing assistant designed to help students and researchers with academic writing tasks. It uses machine learning and natural language processing (NLP) to provide content suggestions, writing feedback, and research assistance. It’s beneficial for writing essays, research papers, literature reviews, and more. Jenni can also help with citations and references and check for plagiarism. 

Pros 

  • AskJenni: Use an AI research assistant that can help answer research questions and provide document-related clarifications. 

  • Citation and Reference Assistance: Jenni can properly format citations and references in styles like APA, MLA, and Chicago. 

  • AI Commands: Jenni can perform tasks like paraphrasing, rewriting, and simplifying existing text. 

  • AI Autocompletion: Jenni can suggest and complete sentences to help you write faster. 

Cons 

  • Limited Content Types: Compared to other AI writing tools like Copy.ai and Jasper, Jenni.ai offers only a limited number of content types, such as blogs, essays, emails, and free-flow writing.  

14. Knewton: The Adaptive Learning Software  

Using artificial intelligence and machine learning algorithms, Knewton allows users to deliver personalized educational content. You can tailor the tool for the academic content according to individual needs and learning styles. 

This is a one-stop and easy-to-use tool for academic learning. Knewton also allows users to analyze student performance data, strengths, weaknesses, and progress. By leveraging AI's benefits, Knewton seeks to improve engagement, making it one of the best online learning platforms. 

Pros 

  • Provide you with a personalized learning experience with the help of adaptive learning. Offer student interaction to keep cheating at bay by offering different questions to each student. 

Cons 

  • The problems in the tool are generic and need to align with the curriculum. Offer feedback and flexible assessment options that impact students’ learning.

How Does An AI Research Assistant Work

Peron Typing - Research Assistant

Literature Search and Retrieval: The Cornerstone of Research

When you start a new research project, you first need to gather existing information on the topic. AI research assistants help you do this quickly and efficiently. They can search vast databases of academic articles, books, and other scholarly materials using relevant keywords. 

Unlike traditional search engines, they also understand the context and meaning behind your queries, providing more accurate and comprehensive results. AI can even identify influential papers, measure citation impact, and suggest related articles to help you grasp the literature surrounding your topic.

Text Summarization and Analysis: Making Sense of the Existing Research

Once you’ve gathered literature on your topic, AI research assistants can help you understand it all. They can identify the most important ideas and information in a document, so you don’t have to read everything in its entirety. AI also organizes similar concepts and themes within a text and can determine the overall sentiment of a document (positive, negative, or neutral). These capabilities allow researchers to quickly understand existing studies and how they relate to their research.

Data Extraction and Organization: Streamlining Your Workflow

AI research assistants make extracting and organizing data from the literature more efficient. For example, they can quickly extract specific data points from text documents, such as names, dates, and numerical values. They can also help clean and organize this data for analysis. These capabilities can significantly reduce researchers' workloads, allowing them to focus on their experiments instead of tedious literature review tasks.

Research Paper Writing Assistance: Getting You Organized

AI can also assist with writing research papers. For instance, AI can suggest outlines based on the research topic and critical points. It can improve the clarity and coherence of writing and suggest alternative ways to express ideas to avoid plagiarism. These capabilities can help researchers produce high-quality papers more efficiently.

Experiment Design and Analysis: Optimizing Your Research

AI can help researchers optimize experimental parameters for maximum efficiency. Once a study is complete, AI can analyze large datasets, identify patterns, and draw conclusions. It can even create visualizations to help researchers understand their data more effectively. 

Collaboration and Knowledge Sharing: Facilitating Teamwork

AI-powered platforms can facilitate collaboration among researchers, enabling knowledge sharing and feedback. They can even help manage citations and references. 

Let Otio be your AI research and writing partner — try Otio for free today!

Supercharge Your Researching Ability With Otio — Try Otio for Free Today

Today's academic and professional researchers face overwhelming complexity. On one hand, the internet has made endless content available at our fingertips. On the other hand, this has created a paradox of choice regarding scholarly research. There are simply too many options. For example, a Google search will return roughly 2.7 million results in 0.78 seconds. 

Were you researching a paper on artificial intelligence? You might need help with the number of studies, articles, and case studies relevant to your topic. Even if you can narrow your search to an appropriate database, like Google Scholar, you’ll still face a daunting reality. Artificial intelligence is a hot topic, and researchers publish new findings daily. 

While this information is critical for your work, sifting through many options can be paralyzing. That does not count the info you’ll find on social media platforms like Twitter or video content on sites like YouTube. With so many options available, it’s no wonder knowledge workers experience research-related anxiety. The complexities of compiling relevant data make anyone want to throw in the towel.   

The Solution: Otio Helps You Collect, Extract, and Create   

Otio provides a single workspace to help researchers manage their workloads and reduce anxiety. With an emphasis on artificial intelligence, Otio allows users to collect a wide range of data sources, extract critical takeaways, and create drafts in a fraction of the time it would take using traditional methods. When using Otio, researchers can go from the reading list to the first draft faster. Along with this, Otio also helps you write research papers or essays faster. Here are the top features that researchers love.   

Collecting Data with Otio  

Otio helps researchers collect a wide range of relevant data sources. From bookmarks, tweets, and extensive books to YouTube videos, Otio enables you to gather your research. Even better, the process is seamless. You don’t have to worry about organizing your information before you begin writing. You can simply collect data into Otio and figure out the details later.   

Extracting Key Takeaways with Otio  

Once you’ve collected enough data, Otio’s artificial intelligence can help you understand everything. The software generates detailed notes on all bookmarks, whether they are YouTube videos, PDFs, articles, or something else. Otio lets you chat with individual links or entire knowledge bases, just like ChatGPT. When you’re ready to start writing, you can let Otio give you a head start by helping you outline your paper. With Otio, you won’t feel so overwhelmed by the amount of research you’ve collected. Instead, you can focus on writing your paper.   

Creating Outputs with Otio  

When you’re ready to start writing, Otio helps you create draft outputs using the sources you’ve collected. The software’s AI-assisted writing features will help you get started and finish your papers faster. Let Otio be your AI research and writing partner try Otio for free today!

Related Reading

Sharly AI Alternatives
AI For Summarizing Research Papers
Literature Review Tools
How To Identify Theoretical Framework In An Article
Graduate School Reading
Research Tools
AI For Academic Research
Research Paper Organizer
Best AI Tools For Research
Zotero Alternatives
Zotero Vs Endnote
ChatGPT For Research Papers
ChatGPT Literature Review
Mendeley Alternative
Unriddle AI Alternatives
Literature Matrix Generator
Research Rabbit
Research Tools
Research Graphic Organizer
Good Websites for Research
Best AI for Research
Research Paper Graphic Organizer
Graphic Organizer Examples
Summary Graphic Organizer
Sequence Graphic Organizer
Paragraph Graphic Organizer
Who What When Where Why Graphic Organizer
Research Project Graphic Organizer
Research Note Taking Graphic Organizer
Graphic Organizer Research Paper Outline
Research Essay Graphic Organizer
Research Notes Graphic Organizer
Translational Research Graphic Organizer
Research Graphic Organizer Template

Join over 80,000 researchers changing the way they read & write

Join over 50,000 researchers changing the way they read & write

Join thousands of other scholars and researchers